The Heart Wants What It Wants: Unpacking Martha Dunnstock's Secret Affection in Heathers
For fans of the iconic 1989 dark comedy Heathers, the question of who Martha Dunnstock, the sweet and often overlooked friend of Veronica Sawyer, has a crush on is a surprisingly persistent one. While Martha isn't the central figure of the film's romantic entanglements, her earnest desires and naive optimism offer a poignant counterpoint to the cynicism and violence that define Westerberg High. So, let's dive deep into the world of Westerberg and find out who has captured Martha's innocent heart.
The Object of Martha's Affection: Jason "J.D." Dean
The answer, in a word, is Jason "J.D." Dean. Yes, the brooding, mysterious, and ultimately homicidal new student played by Christian Slater is the object of Martha Dunnstock's considerable, albeit unrequited, crush.
Martha's feelings for J.D. are first hinted at early in the film when Veronica is lamenting her complicated relationship with J.D. to Martha. Martha, with a dreamy look in her eye, expresses her admiration for him. This sentiment is further solidified during the legendary "Big Fun" party scene. While Veronica is navigating the chaotic social landscape and her own burgeoning feelings for J.D., Martha finds her moment to express her own infatuation.
The "Big Fun" Party Scene: A Moment of Truth
During the raucous party, Martha, with a palpable nervousness, approaches J.D. She has clearly worked up the courage to speak to him. In a scene that is both sweet and heartbreaking, she confesses her feelings. She tells him, quite directly, that she thinks he's "really amazing" and that she "has a crush on him." This is Martha at her most vulnerable and her most genuine.
J.D.'s reaction, while not outright cruel, is certainly dismissive. He’s too preoccupied with his own dark machinations and his complicated relationship with Veronica to reciprocate Martha's earnest declaration. He offers a polite, but ultimately disengaged, acknowledgment of her feelings, before being swept away by other events. This exchange perfectly encapsulates Martha's position in the film: a gentle soul trying to find connection in a world that often overlooks or exploits her.
Why Martha is Drawn to J.D.
But why J.D.? What is it about this volatile outsider that captivates Martha? Several factors likely contribute to her crush:
- His Rebellious Aura: In the hyper-conformist environment of Westerberg High, J.D. stands out. He’s the antithesis of the preppy, often shallow, popular crowd. Martha, who herself seems a bit of an outsider, is likely drawn to his non-conformity and his perceived independence.
- His Mysterious Demeanor: J.D. is enigmatic. He carries an air of danger and intrigue, which can be alluring, especially to someone who might feel like they live a more predictable life. His dark past and brooding intensity likely spark Martha's imagination.
- Veronica's Influence: While Veronica is initially wary of J.D., she is undeniably fascinated by him. Martha, being Veronica's friend, would have been privy to Veronica's descriptions and perhaps even some of Veronica's own conflicted feelings, which might have inadvertently amplified J.D.'s appeal in Martha's eyes.
- His Perceived Vulnerability: Beneath the tough exterior, there are glimpses of J.D.'s own pain and isolation. Martha, with her empathetic nature, might have picked up on these subtle cues and felt a sense of kinship or a desire to "save" him, a common trope in romantic inclinations.
Martha's Role in the Narrative
Martha's crush on J.D. serves a crucial purpose in the narrative. It highlights the dangerous allure of rebellion and the romanticization of troubled individuals, themes that are central to Heathers. Her earnestness provides a stark contrast to the superficiality of the "Heathers" clique and Veronica's own descent into moral ambiguity. Martha represents a pure, albeit misplaced, desire for connection and affection in a world that often seems devoid of it.
Despite her unrequited feelings, Martha remains a kind and loyal friend to Veronica. Her interactions with J.D., while ultimately leading to disappointment for her, are a key element in understanding the complex romantic dynamics and social commentary that make Heathers such a enduring classic.
Frequently Asked Questions about Martha's Crush
How does Martha express her crush on J.D.?
Martha directly confesses her crush to J.D. at the "Big Fun" party. She tells him that she thinks he's "really amazing" and that she has a crush on him, hoping for some reciprocation.
Does J.D. return Martha's feelings?
No, J.D. does not return Martha's feelings. He acknowledges her confession politely but is largely indifferent, as his focus is elsewhere, primarily on Veronica and his own destructive plans.
Why is Martha drawn to J.D.'s rebellious nature?
Martha is likely drawn to J.D.'s rebellious nature because he represents a stark contrast to the conformist and often superficial environment of Westerberg High. His individuality and mysterious aura are appealing, especially to someone who might feel like an outsider.
What does Martha's crush reveal about her character?
Martha's crush reveals her innocent, empathetic, and hopeful nature. It highlights her desire for genuine connection and affection, even in a cynical world. It also showcases her vulnerability and her susceptibility to the romanticized allure of troubled individuals.
