What did Frank Sinatra think of Johnny Mathis
When considering the relationship between two titans of American popular music like Frank Sinatra and Johnny Mathis, it's natural to wonder about their personal opinions of each other's work and careers. Both artists achieved immense success, captivating audiences for decades with their distinctive vocal styles and enduring hit songs. While direct, extensive public declarations from Sinatra about Mathis are not as widely documented as some other contemporary relationships, the available evidence points to a mutual respect and, at times, a clear admiration.
Sinatra's Public Statements and Perceived Opinions
Frank Sinatra, known for his sharp wit and often candid nature, wasn't always effusive in his praise of fellow performers. However, when he did speak about Johnny Mathis, his words carried weight. It's understood that Sinatra recognized Mathis's unique talent and his significant impact on the music industry.
One of the most frequently cited instances of Sinatra's opinion comes from an anecdote where he reportedly said something to the effect of:
"He (Mathis) has a voice that can melt butter."
While the exact wording and context of this quote can vary in retellings, the sentiment remains consistent: Sinatra acknowledged the smooth, almost liquid quality of Mathis's vocal delivery, a hallmark of his singing. This wasn't just a casual observation; for an artist as discerning as Sinatra, it represented a genuine appreciation for a distinct vocal mastery.
Furthermore, it's important to remember the era in which both artists rose to prominence. The landscape of popular music was competitive, yet there was also a sense of camaraderie among many of the leading figures. Sinatra, while often seen as the "Chairman of the Board" with a commanding presence, was also known to support and acknowledge genuine talent.
Johnny Mathis's Perspective on Sinatra
The respect was, without question, mutual. Johnny Mathis has consistently expressed his admiration for Frank Sinatra throughout his career. Mathis has often referred to Sinatra as a primary influence and a benchmark for vocal performance and stage presence. He has spoken about how Sinatra's professionalism, his ability to connect with an audience, and his mastery of phrasing were qualities he himself aspired to.
Mathis has stated in interviews that he considered Sinatra a peer and a legend, and that he learned a great deal by observing Sinatra's career trajectory and his artistic choices. The appreciation Mathis has for Sinatra is a testament to Sinatra's enduring legacy not just as a singer, but as an icon.
Key Aspects of Mathis's Appeal that Sinatra Likely Appreciated
Several aspects of Johnny Mathis's artistry would have likely resonated with Frank Sinatra:
- Vocal Purity and Tone: Mathis is renowned for his exceptionally pure, rich tenor voice, often described as a "velvet" tone. This purity and control are qualities that any great singer, including Sinatra, would recognize and respect.
- Emotional Delivery: While known for romantic ballads, Mathis also possessed a remarkable ability to convey deep emotion in his songs, a skill Sinatra himself was a master of.
- Longevity and Adaptability: Both artists enjoyed remarkably long and successful careers, navigating the changing tides of popular music. Sinatra would have understood the dedication and talent required to maintain such a level of sustained success.
- Mastery of Ballads: Both singers became synonymous with romantic ballads. While their styles differed – Sinatra often with a more conversational, jazz-inflected delivery, and Mathis with a smoother, more overtly romantic approach – the shared genre highlights a common ground in their appeal.
The Broader Context of Their Careers
It's also worth noting that Sinatra and Mathis occupied slightly different, though overlapping, spaces in the music world. Sinatra, while a masterful balladeer, was also deeply rooted in the jazz tradition and had a more pronounced "swing" sensibility. Mathis, while capable of upbeat numbers, is primarily celebrated for his romantic, orchestral pop ballads. This distinction might explain why Sinatra's public comments were perhaps more focused on the sheer vocal quality of Mathis's singing, rather than a direct comparison of stylistic approaches.
In essence, Frank Sinatra, a legend who set the standard for male vocalists for generations, held a clear and positive view of Johnny Mathis. He recognized the inherent talent and the unique vocal gift that made Mathis one of the most beloved singers in American music history. The admiration was reciprocated, creating a silent but significant acknowledgment of greatness between two unparalleled artists.
FAQ Section
How did Frank Sinatra describe Johnny Mathis's voice?
Frank Sinatra is widely reported to have described Johnny Mathis's voice as one that "can melt butter." This comment highlights Sinatra's appreciation for the smooth, rich, and almost liquid quality of Mathis's tenor.
Did Frank Sinatra consider Johnny Mathis a competitor?
While both were highly successful singers in popular music, the evidence suggests Sinatra viewed Mathis more as a peer with distinct talent rather than a direct competitor. Sinatra's reported comments indicate respect for Mathis's vocal abilities.
What did Johnny Mathis think of Frank Sinatra?
Johnny Mathis has consistently expressed deep admiration for Frank Sinatra, viewing him as a major influence and a benchmark for vocal performance and stage presence. Mathis has spoken of learning from Sinatra's career and artistry.
Were Frank Sinatra and Johnny Mathis friends?
While they were contemporaries and respected each other's work, there isn't extensive documentation of a close personal friendship between Frank Sinatra and Johnny Mathis. Their relationship appears to have been characterized by mutual professional respect.
