The Role That Almost Wasn't: Unpacking Who Turned Down *The Devil Wears Prada*
The iconic 2006 film *The Devil Wears Prada* remains a beloved fashion and career classic for many. Anne Hathaway's portrayal of Andy Sachs, the seemingly out-of-place journalist thrust into the cutthroat world of high fashion, is etched in cinematic history. But did you know that the role of Andy wasn't Hathaway's first choice, or rather, it wasn't the first choice of a certain A-list actress who ultimately turned it down? The question that has lingered for many fans is: What actress turned down *The Devil Wears Prada*?
While rumors and speculation have swirled for years, the most consistently cited actress who reportedly turned down the role of Andrea "Andy" Sachs is none other than Rachel McAdams. Yes, the star of *The Notebook* and *Mean Girls* was apparently the initial top pick for the part that would go on to launch Anne Hathaway into a new stratosphere of stardom.
Why Did Rachel McAdams Say No?
This is where the story gets particularly interesting. According to various reports and interviews, McAdams' decision was not about disliking the script or the project itself. Instead, it was reportedly a matter of her career trajectory and her personal desires at the time. After a string of highly successful romantic comedies and teen-focused films, McAdams was reportedly looking to move away from lighter fare and explore more dramatic and challenging roles. She was apparently not interested in starring in another film that might be perceived as a "chick flick," and *The Devil Wears Prada*, despite its sharp wit and underlying themes, could have been categorized as such by some.
Another significant factor often cited is that McAdams wanted to take a break from the spotlight. She had experienced a rapid rise to fame and was seeking a period of respite, wanting to focus on less demanding projects and perhaps even step back from Hollywood for a while. This desire for a more grounded existence seems to have outweighed the allure of a potentially blockbuster role.
It's also worth noting that the role of Miranda Priestly, the formidable editor-in-chief, was famously offered to a host of other actresses before Meryl Streep's legendary performance. While not directly related to who turned down Andy, it highlights the desirability and the competitive nature of securing roles in such a buzzed-about film.
The Domino Effect: How McAdams' "No" Led to Hathaway's "Yes"
When Rachel McAdams declined the role of Andy, the casting directors and producers had to look elsewhere. Anne Hathaway, who had already made a name for herself with films like *The Princess Diaries* and *The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement*, was a strong contender. However, she wasn't the only one. Multiple actresses auditioned and were considered for the part.
Sources close to the production have indicated that Hathaway was incredibly eager to play Andy. She reportedly even auditioned multiple times, impressing the filmmakers with her commitment and understanding of the character. Her ability to embody both the initial wide-eyed innocence and the eventual sophistication of Andy was a key factor. Ultimately, Hathaway's dedication and talent shone through, making her the perfect fit for the role that Rachel McAdams had passed on.
Other Notable Castings and Near Misses
It's a fun Hollywood game to consider the "what ifs" of casting. Beyond Rachel McAdams, the role of Miranda Priestly was famously offered to:
- Meryl Streep herself was not the initial choice. Actresses like Madonna, Catherine Zeta-Jones, and even Angela Lansbury were reportedly considered before Streep accepted and delivered her Oscar-nominated performance.
- For the role of Emily Charlton, played brilliantly by Emily Blunt, other actresses like Kirsten Dunst and Isla Fisher were reportedly considered.
These are just a few examples of how a film's cast can evolve. But the story of Rachel McAdams and the role of Andy Sachs remains one of the most talked-about casting decisions in *The Devil Wears Prada*'s history.
"It's funny how things work out. Sometimes, what seems like a missed opportunity can lead to something even better."
Anne Hathaway's portrayal of Andy Sachs is so ingrained in popular culture that it's hard to imagine anyone else in the role. Her journey from a struggling graduate to a fashion-savvy professional is a central arc of the film, and Hathaway delivered a performance that was both relatable and inspiring.
Frequently Asked Questions About *The Devil Wears Prada* Casting:
Q1: How did Anne Hathaway get the role of Andy Sachs?
Anne Hathaway was reportedly very persistent and passionate about landing the role. She auditioned multiple times and impressed the filmmakers with her dedication and her understanding of the character's transformation. Her strong performance ultimately secured her the part.
Q2: Why did Rachel McAdams turn down *The Devil Wears Prada*?
Rachel McAdams reportedly turned down the role of Andy Sachs because she was looking to move away from romantic comedies and lighter roles. She also expressed a desire to take a break from the intense spotlight of Hollywood fame at that time.
Q3: Who else was considered for the role of Andy Sachs?
While Rachel McAdams is the most frequently cited actress who turned down the role, the producers had a wide array of actresses in mind and considered many before Anne Hathaway was cast. Specific names beyond McAdams are not as widely publicized but it's understood that numerous auditions took place.
Q4: Was Anne Hathaway the studio's first choice?
It's widely reported that Rachel McAdams was the studio's first choice. However, once she declined, Anne Hathaway became a very strong contender and ultimately won the role through her impressive auditions and commitment.
